Did you eat Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal when you were a kid? I did not. My mom stayed far far away from anything sugary but I did have sleepovers haha and that’s where I developed a real taste for it. Now, I will tell you right away that this granola and that cereal are VERY different. I like to keep things on the healthier side but for those of you who have been making my granolas for a while, you will notice that I increased the maple syrup ever so slightly to give this a touch more sweetness. Please feel free to increase or decrease as you see fit.
I also used my homemade cookie butter in this recipe. Let me tell you that this cookie butter alone will change your life and while it can be substituted for another nut butter like peanut or pecan I highly recommend giving that recipe a try and then coming back to this one because it does make a small but significant difference!
In the ever-expanding universe of granola on my website, I’m thrilled to introduce a nostalgic twist with this Gluten-Free Cinnamon Toast Crunch Granola. I’m continually inspired by the flavors of my childhood, transformed into healthier, homemade versions. Today, we’re revisiting those sleepover mornings where Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal was the ultimate treat—only this time, we’re making it guilt-free and gluten-free!
To make your Cinnamon Toast Crunch granola start by preheating your oven and get out a large bowl. Combine all the dry ingredients, ensuring a uniform mixture that will serve as the base for your granola. Meanwhile, in a small pot over medium heat, combine the wet ingredients, stirring continuously until they are fully mixed and warm. This mixture of wet ingredients is then poured over the dry, mixing thoroughly until everything is fully coated.
Distribute the granola evenly across two baking sheets, ensuring the layer isn’t too thick; this is crucial for achieving that desirable crunch. You may be able to get away with one baking sheet if it’s large enough but just be mindful of how thick the layer is. Gently press the granola down onto the pans, compacting it slightly – this step will ensure clumps form as the mixture bakes. Slide the trays into the oven and bake for 20 minutes. Then, carefully turn the pans to ensure even cooking and return them to the oven for an additional 10 minutes or until golden.
After baking, the hardest part comes! Waiting!! Keep your hands off this granola until completely cool. I’ve said it once and I will say it again; this patience is rewarded with the clumpiest and most delicious granola your heart could desire. Once cooled, use a spatula to gently lift the granola off the pans and store it in airtight jars. This step seals in the freshness and crunch, making your homemade Cinnamon Toast Crunch granola a delightful, healthy snack or breakfast topping ready to enjoy whenever the craving strikes.
For those who grew up loving Cinnamon Toast Crunch but are looking for a healthier alternative, this recipe is a dream come true. It’s not just gluten-free but can be customized several ways to suit your preference. This granola isn’t just for breakfast; it’s a treat that can be enjoyed as a snack or a dessert topping or really anytime you like! I love granola for breakfast 🙂
To keep your Cinnamon Toast Crunch Granola fresh and crunchy, store it in airtight jars once it’s completely cooled. It will likely stay fresh longer than you think if it doesn’t get eaten up first! Share it with the family or keep it all to yourself this granola is sure to be enjoyed by everyone.
If this cinnamon-infused delight has sparked your interest, explore these other delicious granola recipes:
Blueberry Tahini Cardamom Granola
Pistachio Pecan Blueberry Granola
Chocolate Peanut Butter Granola
Can you BELIEVE that I now have 18 different granolas on my website? I am floored that I still keep coming up with ideas BUT I do need your help! I would love to hear from my community on what flavours YOU want. I still have a few recipes in my brain but eventually, I will run out of steam so please comment below what you’d like to see next.
subscribe to my mailing list to get the latest recipes, promo codes to my favourite brands and more!
Join my mailing list and be the first to get my recipes, discounts to brands I love and more! I promise not to spam you.
13 Responses
Thank you Teri Ann for this delicious Cinnamon Toast Crunch granola recipe. I made a batch this morning to share with my daughters. I made a half batch so I found the heat a bit high (my oven runs on the hotter side) so I found cutting the time back by 10 mins worked for me, while sill turning the pan for last 10 mins. Really satisfying and delicious!
Hey Hilary, I am so happy you enjoyed this recipe!
Can you clarify why the cinnamon amount is divided? (Making it now, smells delicious!)
Hey Nancy, the cinnamon is divided so that it goes into the dry and wet ingredients! I found this just made it as cinnamony as possible!
Thanks
These all sound yummy thank you.
I hope you enjoy!
Why is the 2 tbsp. cinnamon divided? What do you do with the other tbsp?
Thank you for the comment Karen! Please see modified recipe.
Where does the second tbsp of cinnamon go?
one in the wet and one in dry, thanks Bi
I made this yesterday & it’s delicious! I’ve been making granola for yrs & always cook it for 2hrs in a long & slow process. I was surprised to still get such big clusters when it cooked for such a short amount of time! Will defs be making this & trying other recipes again. Thank you!
Hey Kristy! So happy you made it and was a delightful process for you! Can’t wait for you to try some others 🙂